Video Game Book Review — “Mass Effect: Revelation”

RevelationSince finishing the Citadel DLC a few weeks ago, Drew Karpyshyn’s novel Mass Effect: Revelation has been the medicine for my Mass Effect withdrawals. It’s a book that feels a lot like a video game, jumping from one point-of-view to another as the chapters turn. It may not be absolutely stellar, but as a new way to explore the Mass Effect universe, it’s a riveting read that I recommend to fans of the games.

Showdown: Anderson vs. Saren

Revelation is almost an origin story for Alliance Lieutenant David Anderson. It’s a prequel to the first Mass Effect game, for which Karpyshyn was the lead writer.

David Anderson

The novel follows Anderson, in his late 20’s and in the midst of a distant divorce, as he tracks down Alliance scientist Kahlee Sanders. The top-secret research base at Sidon has been blown to pieces, and she’s the suspected traitor. Believing her innocent, Anderson wants to protect her, but the only way to do that is to find out what was going on behind the scenes at Sidon.

But someone else is also trying to unravel the true Sidon story: Saren, a turian Spectre with special privileges from the Citadel Council. Seeing him at work outside of the first Mass Effect game is a thrill, as he’s absolutely ruthless. (The scary thing is that he occasionally reminds me of my renegade Shepard, which makes me feel like I probably should have had her play nicer sometimes…) As you can imagine, when he and good-hearted Anderson are forced to work together, they clash.

Saren

Unfortunately, Saren is a very one-sided character throughout the book, with no real redeeming features. He spits out a lot of silly lines about how tough he is, such as: “Some Spectres arrest people,” Saren said, his tone casual. “I don’t.” (Bang bang — you’re dead.)

Though his racism against humans makes some sense given the recent First Contact War between turians and humans, his general cruelty is never really explained. Apparently his brother died in the war, but that’s not an excuse for his awful personality. It’s still interesting to finally get inside his head during his viewpoint chapters — it just leaves a bad taste when the ending hits without him being fully explored as a realistic character.

Kahlee Sanders

Lieutenant Anderson and Kahlee Sanders are much more well-rounded, and their relationship develops naturally over the course of the book. In fact, Sanders is probably my favorite character in the book: clever, careful, and capable of defending herself and making quick decisions, even if they’re dangerous. Revelation fills in a lot of the details hinted at in Mass Effect 3, particularly during the Grissom Academy mission — except that this book came before the third game. It’s very cool to see how the games play off the books (and not just the other way around), creating an elaborate history for the Mass Effect universe.

Chapters flit from one character to another, focusing on Anderson, Sanders, Saren, and several of the enemies in the book. One notable chapter even takes the POV of a character who is killed off by the end of the chapter — yet it’s a fantastic bit of characterization for Saren, who swoops into the room toward the end of the scene. It’s almost as if Karpyshyn thought out each scenario in detail, then decided which viewpoint would be most engaging for experiencing that scenario. This method allows readers to see each of the main characters in many different lights — both positive and negative — which adds depth.

Racism as Cultural Characterization

Aside from some awkward physical descriptions, the characterization of the different races and cultures is excellent. Karpyshyn seems to delight in pointing out the odd or off-putting details of alien races. And when you’re reading a scene from an alien’s perspective, you may find yourself in the midst of a disparaging description of humans. The racism can be insightful.

However, one slight surprise regarding racism, for me, is hearing about Anderson’s views on interspecies sex. In spite of his open-mindedness, “that kind of thing normally repulsed him. With the asari, however, he could understand the attraction.” Considering Anderson’s self-alleged open-mindedness and the interspecies romances that take place in the games, this revelation hits me wrong. However, it’s definitely in keeping with the first game, which only has three romanceable characters in total: two humans and one asari. I don’t know if Karpyshyn hadn’t thought that far ahead (considering future games have interspecies romances) or if this really is just how Anderson thinks.

For me, Revelation’s most successful scenes are tense conversations between characters with different, hidden agendas. Some of these conversations even show cultural details moving the story forward. For instance, in a conversation between a krogan and batarian, each tilts his head in certain directions to batariancommunicate according to batarian custom. At one point, the krogan tilts his head to the left as a sign of respect; in response, the batarian tilts his head to the right, which indicates that he’s accepting an apology and makes it seem that his honor has been insulted — and he’s being gracious to forgive. I love seeing these tense conversations play out not only in words, but also in culture-specific body language, as this wouldn’t quite work in the visual medium of a game without the explanations.

A Whole Lot of Codex Entries

Still, Revelation suffers from too much exposition at times, and it’s awkward. For instance, this paragraph also happens to be one single sentence:

Given that most species at the Citadel had ascended to interstellar flight through the discovery and adaptation of caches of Prothean technology on planets within the same solar system as their respective home worlds, many anthropologists believed the Protheans had played some role in evolution throughout the galaxy.

Was there really no better way to word that? Maybe Karpyshyn just felt the need to release those prepositions into the wild like little doves.

Of course, I appreciate the descriptions in some places — learning about the Citadel Conventions banning artificial intelligence is particularly insightful — but they’re usually cumbersome. Most likely, fans of the games already know most of the information. Reading these lengthy passages is akin to re-reading old codex entries when you really just want to get back into the combat.

Final Thoughts

Despite the clunky exposition, Mass Effect: Revelation moves along at breakneck speed overall. Scenes are mostly dialogue and action, and nearly every chapter ends on a cliffhanger. If you’re not familiar with the Mass Effect games, Karpyshyn sets up the universe well enough for you to jump in and follow the story, but this is really a book for the fans.

To be honest, Revelation’s prose may seem creaky or unpolished compared to prose in other science fiction novels. Its characterization is spotty in places. It’s unashamed to go for the badass one-liners that probably wouldn’t work any better in a video game. But it’s Mass Effect, and seeing the clash between Anderson and Saren play out, along with the underlying struggle of humanity finding its place in the greater galaxy, is truly absorbing.

— Ashley

7 Comments Add yours

  1. xandurse says:

    I quite enjoyed the first three Mass Effect books and yes, it’s really satisfying for the final game to take so many cues back from them. I’d warn you, however, to stay the heck away from the 4th one, written by the guy famous for writing the worst Halo novel, lol. The 4th one is not only full of incredible lore mistakes – the kinds of mistakes you just couldn’t make if you played even one of the games once – but is also oddly bleak. This remainder of this sentence is a big spoiler, but frankly the book seems to be written with a singular purpose in mind: tie off all the loose ends the novels produced so as to not have to explain why they *arent* in Mass Effect 3… Read the next two books, though: you’ll learn a lot more about biotic training, the Quarian Flotilla, and discover why everyone who read through them was looking forward to killing Kai Leng even before his fatal run-in with Thane. They’ll definitely increase your enjoyment of the last game. One last semi-relevant thing: BioWare is doing a survey on the ME3 multiplayer maps. Go to their blog for a link.

    1. Yeah, I’d like to give the next one a try at some point. I mean, I read this one for the lore but found it much more enjoyable that I expected, because it’s really fast-paced! (And I would loooove to find out more about biotics training in future books…) Shame about the 4th one, though. I actually didn’t realize there was a 4th one until now… but I guess that’s what happens when Karpyshyn isn’t there anymore.

      Thanks for the survey tip, I’ll check out their blog now.

  2. Sam Leung says:

    This sounds really interesting! I had considered reading this before I played ME3, but to be honest, I sort of expected it to be rubbish. I knew they had woven elements of the book into ME3, but I hadn’t realised quite how extensively they had done so. I also like the sound of the perspective switching to different characters. It sounds like quite an interesting way to tell the story and to see the main characters from different points of view. Considering we’ve only seen Anderson from Shepard’s POV, I’d like to see what other people think of him!
    I’m definitely looking forward to picking this up sometime now and getting more Mass Effect in the process!

    1. Yay, I hope you like it too! It is cool to see Anderson when he was in his 20’s, long before Shepard came onto the scene. As a sci-fi book, it’s just okay… BUT it has a lot more action and tense moments than I expected! It’s also a quick read.

  3. simpleek says:

    I really need to pick up these books. Like you, any reason to extend the ME world after finishing all three games, I’ll take it! I also wanted to read more about Anderson and his time with Saren. Anderson is one of my favorite characters in the series. :)

    1. I know, this year I’ve been thinking it’s about time for me to read these books already! And I agree, Anderson is a great character. =)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s